Off-by-one error

Off-by-one error

An off-by-one error (OBOE) is a logical error involving the discrete equivalent of a boundary condition. It often occurs in computer programming when an iterative loop iterates one time too many or too few. Usually this problem arises when a programmer fails to take into account that a sequence starts at zero rather than one (as with array indices in many languages), or makes mistakes such as using "is less than or equal to" where "is less than" should have been used in a comparison. This can also occur in a mathematical context.

Contents

Looping over arrays

Consider an array of items, and items m through n (inclusive) are to be processed. How many items are there? An intuitive answer may be n−m, but that is off by one, exhibiting a fencepost error; the correct answer is n−m+1.

For this reason, ranges in computing are often represented by half-open intervals; the range from m to n (inclusive) is represented by the range from m (inclusive) to n+1 (exclusive) to avoid fencepost errors. For example, a loop that iterates five times can be written as a half-open interval from 0 to 5:

for (i = 0; i < 5; i++) {
    /* Body of the loop */
}

The loop body is executed first of all with i equal to 0; i then becomes 1, 2, 3, and finally 4 on successive iterations. At that point, i becomes 5, so i < 5 is false and the loop ends. However, if the comparison used were <= (less than or equal to), the loop would be carried out six times: i takes the values 0, 1, 2, 3, 4, and 5. Likewise, if i were initialized to 1 rather than 0, there would only be four iterations: i takes the values 1, 2, 3, and 4. Both of these alternatives can cause off-by-one errors.

Another such error can occur if a do-while loop is used in place of a while loop (or vice versa.) A do-while loop is guaranteed to run at least once.

Array-related confusion may also result from differences in programming languages. Numbering from 0 is most common, but some languages start array numbering with 1. Pascal has arrays with user-defined indices. This makes it possible to model the array indices after the problem domain.

Fencepost error

A straight fence with n sections has n+1 posts

A fencepost error (occasionally called a "telegraph pole" or "lamp-post" error) is a specific type of off-by-one error. The following problem illustrates the error:

If you build a straight fence 100m long with posts 10m apart, how many posts do you need?

The intuitive answer 10 is wrong. The fence has 10 sections, but 11 posts.

The reverse error occurs when the number of posts is known and the number of sections is assumed to be the same. The actual number of sections is one fewer than the number of posts. A similar problem involves a shoe with ten pairs of eyelets. When calculating the total length of shoelace required, the length needed to go from one pair of eyelets to the next higher pair of eyelets should be counted only nine times and not ten.

More generally, the problem can be stated as follows:

If you have n telegraph poles, how many gaps are there between them?

The correct answer may be n - 1, n or n + 1, depending on the conditions. The precise problem definition must be carefully considered, as the setup for one scenario may give the wrong answer for other scenarios.

Fencepost errors can also occur in units other than length. For example, the Time Pyramid, consisting of 120 blocks placed at 10 year intervals between blocks, is scheduled to take 1190 (not 1200) years to build, from the installation of the first block to the last block.

"Fencepost error" can[citation needed], in rare occasions, refer to an error induced by unexpected regularities in input values, which can (for instance) completely thwart a theoretically efficient binary tree or hash function implementation. This error involves the difference between expected and worst case behaviours of an algorithm.

Security implications

A common off-by-one error which results in a security related bug is caused by misuse of the libc strncat routine. A common misconception with strncat is that the guaranteed null termination will not write beyond the maximum length. In reality it will write a terminating null character one byte beyond the maximum length specified. The following code contains such a bug:

void foo (char *s) {
    char buf[15];
    memset(buf, 0, sizeof(buf));
    strncat(buf, s, sizeof(buf)); // Final parameter should be: sizeof(buf)-1
    return;
}

Off-by-one errors are common in using the C library because it is not consistent with respect to whether one needs to subtract 1 byte -- functions like fgets() and strncpy will never write past the length given them (fgets() subtracts 1 itself, and only retrieves (length - 1) bytes), whereas others, like strncat will write past the length given them. So the programmer has to remember for which functions he or she needs to subtract 1.

On some systems (little endian architectures in particular) this can result in the overwriting of the least significant byte of the frame pointer. This can cause an exploitable condition where an attacker can hijack the local variables for the calling routine.

One approach that often helps avoid such problems is to use variants of these functions that calculate how much to write based on the total length of the buffer, rather than the maximum number of characters to write. Such functions include strlcat and strlcpy, and are often considered "safer" because they make it easier to avoid accidentally writing past the end of a buffer. (In the code example above, calling strlcat(buf, s, sizeof(buf)) instead would remove the bug.)

See also

References


Wikimedia Foundation. 2010.

Игры ⚽ Поможем сделать НИР

Look at other dictionaries:

  • Off-by-one-Error — Ein Off By One Error (deutsch etwa Um Eins daneben Fehler) oder ±1 Problem bezeichnet eine bestimmte Art von Programmierfehlern, die bei der Entwicklung von Software unterlaufen können und meist ein spezieller Fall des Zaunpfahlproblems, eines… …   Deutsch Wikipedia

  • Off-by-one error — Ein Off By One Error (deutsch etwa Um Eins daneben Fehler) oder +/ 1 Problem bezeichnet eine bestimmte Art von Programmierfehlern, die bei der Entwicklung von Software unterlaufen können und meist ein spezieller Fall des Zaunpfahlproblems, eines… …   Deutsch Wikipedia

  • off-by-one error — /ɒf baɪ ˈwʌn ɛrə/ (say of buy wun eruh) noun Computers a programming error which results in a repeated loop iterating once too often, frequently caused by the fact that the programmer fails to appreciate that the sequence has started at 0 rather… …  

  • Off-by-one — Ein Off By One Error (deutsch etwa Um Eins daneben Fehler) oder +/ 1 Problem bezeichnet eine bestimmte Art von Programmierfehlern, die bei der Entwicklung von Software unterlaufen können und meist ein spezieller Fall des Zaunpfahlproblems, eines… …   Deutsch Wikipedia

  • Off by one — Ein Off By One Error (deutsch etwa Um Eins daneben Fehler) oder +/ 1 Problem bezeichnet eine bestimmte Art von Programmierfehlern, die bei der Entwicklung von Software unterlaufen können und meist ein spezieller Fall des Zaunpfahlproblems, eines… …   Deutsch Wikipedia

  • One Ring — The One Ring is a fictional artifact that appears as the central plot element in J. R. R. Tolkien s Middle earth fantasy novels. It is described in an earlier story, The Hobbit (1937), as a magic ring of invisibility. The sequel The Lord of the… …   Wikipedia

  • one-off — ➔ one time * * * Ⅰ. one off UK US /ˌwʌnˈɒf/ adjective [before noun] UK ► (US one shot) produced or happening only once: »The London store is stocking 12 exclusive, one off designs. »a one off opportunity/chance »a …   Financial and business terms

  • One-Two-GO Airlines Flight 269 — Crash scene Accident summary Date September 16 2007 …   Wikipedia

  • off — off1 [ôf, äf] adv. [LME var. of of,OF1, later generalized for all occurrences of of in stressed positions] 1. so as to be or keep away, at a distance, to a side, etc. [to move off, to ward off] 2. so as to be measured, divided, etc. [to pace off …   English World dictionary

  • One of Us (ABBA song) — One of Us Single by ABBA from the album The Visitors B side …   Wikipedia

Share the article and excerpts

Direct link
Do a right-click on the link above
and select “Copy Link”