A fortiori argument

A fortiori argument

The Latin phrase _la. argumentum a fortiori literally means one of the following:
* "from the stronger"
* "even more so"
* "with even stronger reason"It denotes a proof of a claim by means of an already proved stronger claim. For example, if it is forbidden to ride a bike with an extra passenger, then it is also forbidden to ride a bike with two extra passengers. Or, if one can lift a 100 lb object, then it follows that one can lift a 50 lb object.

There are two types of the a fortiori argument:
* a maiore ad minus: from bigger to smaller
* a minore ad maius: from smaller to bigger

The a fortiori argument is most often used in order to reinforce a claim, though sometimes also to incorrectly justify a claim taking it as a premise (petitio principii).

This argument is regularly used in Jewish Law under the name Kal V'Chomer (Easy and Hard). If one can do the hard thing, then it follows that one can do the easy thing, and if one cannot do the easy thing then it follows that one cannot do the hard thing.

References

* Grabenhorst, Thomas K.: "Das _la. argumentum a fortiori", Verlag „Peter Lang“ 1990 ISBN-Nummer 3-631-43261-5
* Schneider: "Logik für Juristen", S. 158ff.


Wikimedia Foundation. 2010.

Игры ⚽ Нужен реферат?

Look at other dictionaries:

  • argument — [ argymɑ̃ ] n. m. • 1160; lat. argumentum → arguer 1 ♦ Raisonnement destiné à prouver ou à réfuter une proposition, et par ext. Preuve à l appui ou à l encontre d une proposition. ⇒ raisonnement; argumentation, démonstration; preuve, raison.… …   Encyclopédie Universelle

  • Argument from love — The Argument from love is an argument for the existence of God, as against materialism and reductionist forms of physicalism.Outline of argumentThe deep relationship of theism in general, and Christianity in particular, and love goes back to the… …   Wikipedia

  • Argument — Grund; Beleg; Beweisgrund; Begründung; Prämisse; Beweis * * * Ar|gu|ment [argu mɛnt], das; [e]s, e: etwas, was zur Rechtfertigung, Begründung oder als Beweis vorgebracht wird: ein stichhaltiges, schlagendes Argument; dieses Argument überzeugt… …   Universal-Lexikon

  • À fortiori — A fortiori A fortiori est une locution latine adverbiale signifiant « pour une raison plus forte » (définition apparue vers 1834). Le nouveau Petit Robert 2009 donne comme définition : « En concluant de la vérité d une… …   Wikipédia en Français

  • a fortiori — a for·ti·o·ri /ˌā ˌfȯr shē ōr ˌī, ˌä ˌfȯr shē ōr ē, ˌfȯr tē / adv [New Latin, from the stronger (argument)]: all the more certainly: with greater reason: with still more convincing force used in drawing a conclusion that is thought to be even… …   Law dictionary

  • A fortiori — est une locution latine adverbiale signifiant « pour une raison plus forte ». L argument a fortiori est un argument qui est souvent présenté en même temps que les arguments a pari et a contrario, notamment dans plusieurs manuels de… …   Wikipédia en Français

  • a fortiori — adverb Etymology: New Latin, literally, from the stronger (argument) Date: 1561 with greater reason or more convincing force used in drawing a conclusion that is inferred to be even more certain than another < the man of prejudice is, a fortiori …   New Collegiate Dictionary

  • a fortiori — [ˌeɪ fɔ:tɪ ɔ:rʌɪ, ˌα:, ri:] adverb & adjective with a yet stronger reason than a conclusion previously accepted. Origin C17: L., from a fortiori argumento from stronger argument …   English new terms dictionary

  • a fortiori — [ā΄ fôr΄shē ôr′ī΄] adv., adj. [L, lit., for a stronger (reason)] all the more: said of a conclusion that follows with even greater logical necessity than another already accepted in the argument …   English World dictionary

  • a fortiori — /ey forshiyoray/ With stronger reason; much more. A term used in logic to denote an argument to the effect that because one ascertained fact exists, therefore another, which is included in it, or analogous to it, and which is less improbable,… …   Black's law dictionary

Share the article and excerpts

Direct link
Do a right-click on the link above
and select “Copy Link”